Two Reviewers, Opposite Recommendations: What a Handling Editor Actually Does
A split is not a tie to be broken. A reconciliation worksheet for handling editors, a triage for unusable reports, and the decision letter that saves...
Put the decision first, rank reviewer points as required or optional, and settle conflicting requests yourself...
A masthead listing is a loan of your reputation, easier to give than to take back. Twelve questions to send be...
Editors publishing in their own journals is normal. Editors deciding on their own manuscripts is not. Six ques...
“Legitimate journals are transparent about their fees, peer review and editorial board — verify all three before you submit.”
A split is not a tie to be broken. A reconciliation worksheet for handling editors, a triage for unusable reports, and the decision letter that saves...
Rejected, then offered a move to another journal? Pin down the consent, the fee, the review standard and the reviewer reports in writing before you re...
A well-run special issue gathers the best current work on a topic. A badly run one has become a favourite vehicle for paper mills. Here is how to tell...
Running peer review well is the heart of an editor's job. Here is how to select reviewers, manage the process fairly, and handle problems — in line wi...
Behind every published paper is a handling editor. Learn what they do, how editorial decisions are reached, and the principles that keep the process f...
Directive Publications is an open-access publisher — every article peer-reviewed, Crossref-registered, and free to read under CC BY 4.0.